| Platinum | Hot Mess Burgers and Fries |
| Gold | Busy Bee Diner |
| Silver | Zip's Hamburgers & Fish |
| Bronze | Frost Me Sweet |
| Top Pick | Ann's Best Creole & Soul Food |
| Top Pick | Bob's Burgers & Brew |
| Top Pick | Brady's Brats and Burgers |
| Top Pick | Bruchi's |
| Top Pick | Burger Ranch |
| Top Pick | The Village Bistro |