| Platinum | Casa Mia |
| Gold | Pacific Pasta & Grill |
| Silver | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Bella Italia |
| Top Pick | Europa Italian & Spanish Cuisine |
| Top Pick | Italiano's Serious Pies & Pasta |
| Top Pick | LA Bella Vita Kitchen and Bar |
| Top Pick | Nothing But Noodles |
| Top Pick | Stick+Stone |
| Top Pick | Taqueria El Sazon |